
I was one of the many people who was starting to wonder about LOST last season. Was there really a master plan, a grand answer to all our questions?
Happily the illusion of a seamless, interconnected master plan on LOST has been restored this season. I still have a nagging feeling like they’re making some of this stuff up as they go along, but if that’s true, they’re doing a good job of covering it up.
My faith was rekindled and my curiosity was re-piqued by the 3rd season finale, which gave us our first glimpse of the Oceanic Six timeline and launched an entirely new sub-mystery. Who are the Oceanic Six? Does Jack think that beard looks flattering? Because it doesn’t.
The two fresh episodes so far in season four have expanded on the Oceanic Six mystery as well as introducing the mysterious and potentially menacing Freighter People – both welcome developments in the world of LOST.
At first I thought the Oceanic Six Timeline was a strange choice and that the LOST creators were writing themselves into a corner, so to speak. If Jack, Kate, Hurley and three others made it off the island, there is no way they can die in the Island Timeline, right? By taking three major characters and putting them in the “safe box” it eliminates a certain element of suspense. If somebody holds a gun to Jack’s head – big deal, we know he’s not going to die, right? This assumes of course that the Island Timeline and the Oceanic Six Timeline are part of a linear and chronological Mega Timeline and that we’re not talking about alternate realities and parallel time, of course, but nothing should be ruled out.
Then I realized that for me, the allure of LOST lies not as much in a sense of involvement in the fate of individual characters (aside from wishing that Nikki and Paulo would die), but rather in the unraveling of LOST’s puzzles and puzzles-within-puzzles-wrapped-in-enigmas. Don’t get me wrong, I was bummed out when Charlie (apparently) died, but the appeal of LOST is in the mystery and wonder, not in the body count. It’s not so much “who is going to survive?” as it is “what the hell is going on?”
On those grounds, the new season of LOST has been a big success so far, rekindling the sense of awe and wonder that the show had in those first two seasons, when viewers felt like they were catching fleeting but incomplete glimpses of a carefully designed stained glass window of awesomeness.
As it should be, each episode parses out some answers and information while leaving the viewer with fresh new unanswered questions. I certainly have some questions I would like answers to:
-Who was in that coffin? Is he or she one of the Oceanic Six who made it off the island and then died, or did the Oceanic Six bring Dead Person home with them?
-In episode 4.1, why the hell did Jack let Ben go with Locke of all people?
-Is Jack losing it? He would have actually killed Locke if the gun had a bullet. Then he lets Ben out of his custody? Get it together Jack.
-Did Ghost Charlie get an afterlife makeover, or was Hurley hallucinating? Perhaps Ghost Charlie is some sort of ideal, perfected Charlie with fabulous hair that exists in Hurley’s mind only.
-How could Hurley do a cannonball on a big flat beach like that? I think the show creators fudged a little on this one, because everyone knows you can’t execute a cannonball unless you actually jump from a height into water.
- If the Freighter People are just on the island to find/kill Ben, why aren’t they a team of commandos instead of a motley team consisting of drunk pilot, anthropologist, brilliant head case, and rude psychic? Why this particular group of people with these particular skills? What are they really up to?
-What is the Smoke Monster, anyway? I was happy that was the first thing that Locke asked Ben when he had him at gunpoint. It’d be the first thing I’d ask, too. I would die unhappy if I made it off the island but never found out what that thing was…
- Is Ben going to get the crap beaten out of him in every episode this season? He gets smacked once in episode 4.1 and beaten up twice by Sawyer in episode 4.2. Perhaps this is part of a welcome trend, and by the end of the season people will just be lining up to abuse Ben.
-Why did Kate look so fabulous in the Oceanic Six timeline? Isn’t she a wanted woman, or did her freckle-free complexion indicate that she leaves her legal troubles behind her in the future?
It’s nice to have lots of questions about LOST again. They’re good questions, too – better than asking “Is there a point to all this?” Because once again, I believe there is a point, a master plan, and a grand design. And that’s why we signed up in the first place.
--Dave Campbell